The hardest part was supposed to be walking through the door.
For one man in his early 30s, attending a speed-dating event meant stepping outside a familiar, anxiety-enforced bubble. He went anyway. And, for a while, it felt worth it.
The conversations were enjoyable. He felt he was making genuine connections. A few people caught his interest, and he left excited about what might come next—even if that turned out to be friendship rather than romance.
Then the follow-up email arrived.y
The event’s system was straightforward: participants checked boxes beside the names of people they wanted to see again, and the organizer connected those whose interest was mutual. He had selected twelve people. None had selected him back.
What had felt like an encouraging evening suddenly became something else: an apparent confirmation of the fears he had brought into the room.
“It was an immense blow to my already struggling self-confidence,” he wrote.
More Than One Disappointing Email
To understand why the result hurt so much, it helps to understand what getting to that event had required.
He described growing up as a sensitive child whose parents and teachers encouraged him to bottle up his emotions. In his Muslim upbringing, he said, he was taught to avoid settings involving alcohol, that spending time around men was sinful, and that being gay was worse.
He left the religion at 23. But leaving did not mean that dating suddenly became easy.
Now in his early 30s, he is in therapy and still struggling to pursue the intimacy he wants. Meanwhile, watching peers date and find partners makes him feel as though everyone else has access to a process he cannot quite figure out.
The familiar questions and reassurances only sharpen that frustration: Why aren’t you dating? Why aren’t you married? You’re so kind and sweet—anyone would be glad to date you.
Intended as encouragement, those words can sound painfully disconnected from his actual experience.
He has friends. He has community. What he wants is not a replacement for those relationships, but a romantic connection alongside them. Yet thinking about that desire too much can send him spiraling, so he returns to the response he learned early: push it down.
The speed-dating disappointment landed in the middle of that struggle.
“I really, really don’t want this incredibly negative experience to influence me from trying again,” he wrote. “But being rejected by twelve people at once is not helping.”
The Internet’s Answer: Keep Going. But How?
The responses to his account ranged from compassionate to blunt. Many returned to the same idea: dating involves rejection, and getting rejected does not necessarily mean you did anything wrong.
One commenter drew a comparison with working as an actor. Auditions had taught them that a rejection could happen for many reasons, including reasons that had little to do with their ability. They saw a similar uncertainty in dating: you can show up, do your part, and still not be what someone else is looking for.
Others called it a numbers game. Their argument was that meeting more people creates more opportunities for mutual interest—and that investing too much meaning in any single encounter makes every disappointment harder to absorb.
One person illustrated the point with a memory of a college co-worker moving through a bar, striking up conversations and moving on whenever the interest was not returned. Eventually, he met someone who reciprocated.
That story offers a model of persistence. It also reveals the gap between knowing what to do and feeling able to do it. For someone already describing anxiety as a “death grip,” simply moving on to the next conversation is precisely the difficult part.
Several replies urged him to experience so much rejection that it would eventually stop bothering him. Others offered a gentler version of persistence: take a break, bring a friend, or approach another event as an evening of conversation rather than a test of whether a relationship is finally about to begin.
Those responses did not all agree on how tough he needed to become. They did, however, suggest different ways of measuring what an evening like this could offer.
A Good Conversation Is Still a Good Conversation
One of the most painful details in his account is that he initially enjoyed himself.
The disappointing email seemed to overwrite that experience. Conversations that had felt warm and promising now appeared, in retrospect, to be evidence that he had misread the room.
But the account leaves room for a less punishing interpretation: the conversations may have been enjoyable without producing mutual romantic interest. His pleasure in meeting those people did not have to be mistaken simply because they did not choose to pursue him.
The event answered a narrow question: did any of the twelve people he selected also select him? It did not explain their decisions. It did not establish how future encounters would go. And it did not erase the fact that he had done something he found frightening and managed to enjoy parts of it.
Some commenters who had attended similar events described finding value beyond a match. One said going with a friend made the experience more enjoyable. Another described becoming less socially anxious over time and making friends even when romance did not develop.
Their experiences were not promises about what would happen for him. They offered a different possibility: an event could be worthwhile without delivering the outcome that prompted someone to attend.
The Problem With “Just Get a Thicker Skin”
Among the more sympathetic replies was one from another self-described sensitive man, who acknowledged how exhausting dating could feel. His response did not pretend that one successful match would resolve everything. Mutual interest could still lead to disappointment later.
That was hardly a cheerful sales pitch for getting back out there. But it recognized something the tougher responses sometimes missed: this man was not asking to be told that rejection exists. He had just experienced it. He was trying to work out how to keep it from becoming a verdict on his worth.
Likewise, the comments urging him to “just” love himself or stop caring offered little acknowledgment of the history he had described. He was already in therapy. He had already built friendships and community. He had already taken the risk of attending.
His frustration was not that he had done nothing and received nothing. It was that he had made a difficult effort and was now struggling to hold on to the courage that got him there.
An Ending Without a Match
By the time he added an update, something had shifted—not in his dating prospects, but in how he felt after talking about them.
He thanked the people who had offered grounding perspectives and reality checks. He said he had needed to vent, and getting the feelings out had helped.
Then came a joke: he was making his therapist “a rich man this month.”
There was no sudden romantic turnaround. No late message from the organizer. No neat ending in which persistence immediately paid off.
Instead, there was a smaller change. Someone who had learned to bottle up difficult feelings had expressed them, been heard, and felt a little better.
The email still said there were no mutual matches. For the moment, it no longer had to say everything else he feared about himself.







Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.